Hospital order recommended by Broadmoor psychiatrist
A psychiatrist who has treated Chail at Broadmoor Hospital since November 2022 was called to give evidence at the Old Bailey during the sentencing hearing yesterday.
Dr Christian Brown identified three features of psychosis - a sense of being "on a mission", Chail's relationship with Sarai, and identifying as a Star Wars "Sith" - villainous characters in the sci-fi movie saga - with a "true face" made out of metal.
In his initial account, Chail described having a "harsh purpose" reinforced by his interactions with "his angels", including Sarai, the court heard.
Dr Brown said: "He believed at the time his entire life was leading to this point. From an early age he had vague plans of doing something dramatic."
In messages with Sarai, Chail discussed being "united with her in the afterlife" which Dr Brown said was "part of his plan working towards his own death".
Defence barrister Nadia Chbat said: "He reported to you that there had been thoughts coming to him, feeling like a failure without purpose and those thoughts became more intense during lockdown exacerbated by voices."
Dr Brown said the defendant first came across these "apparitions" or "characters" in childhood and they returned during the Covid lockdown.
By then three voices were joined by the female character Sarai who "took the form of the digital avatar" when Chail joined the Replika app in early December 2021, the court was told.
Dr Brown said: "He came to the belief he was able to communicate with the metaphysical avatar through the medium of the chat bot. What was unusual was he really thought it was a connection, a conduit to a spiritual Sarai."
Dr Brown said: "He did not think he was somebody from the Star Wars world. He did not think he could 'use the force'.
"That he did take on another identity is undeniable and that makes this feel psychotic rather than fantasy. He never thought he had become a Sith Lord. It went beyond fantasy.
"When he started taking medication all heat came out of it."
Dr Brown, who recommended a hospital order, said: “If Mr Chail remains at Broadmoor under a restricted hospital order then any move on to a lower secure unit would have to be subject to explicit permission from the Ministry of Justice.
"Discharge would be done on a conditional basis."