Teacher 'poisoned husband with deadly flower' for six weeks as he noticed signs

554     0
Sarah Scheffer has been charged with attempted murder (Image: Cole County Sheriff
Sarah Scheffer has been charged with attempted murder (Image: Cole County Sheriff's Office)

A teacher has been accused of trying to poison her husband's smoothie with a deadly flower.

Sarah Scheffer, 37, from Missouri, was arrested after her husband recorded her allegedly adding the highly poisonous Lily of the Valley to his smoothie.

The husband suspected that she had been poisoning his food and drinks for weeks, as he had been experiencing strange symptoms. He described eight instances where he felt extremely tired, confused, and nauseous after consuming the food or drink she provided.

In a shocking turn of events, when confronted by her husband about a bitter-tasting beverage she gave him, Scheffer initially claimed she had urinated in it. She then confessed to spiking it with an "industrial state adhesive," before denying she put anything in it at all.

READ MORE: Baby clothing CEO fires mum who asked to work remotely as prem baby in hospital

Tragedy as 13-month-old boy dies after the stolen car he was in crashed qeithidttiqrtinvTragedy as 13-month-old boy dies after the stolen car he was in crashed
Teacher 'poisoned husband with deadly flower' for six weeks as he noticed signsSarah Scheffer, 37, and her husband Matthew (Matthew Scheffer/Instagram)

A woman was caught on a hidden camera by her husband, allegedly adding a poisonous plant to his smoothie. The plant, 'lily of the valley', can "slow down the heart and cause irregular heart rhythm", according to the National Capital Poison Centre.

The suspicious smoothie was taken by the police for testing. When questioned, the woman reportedly admitted to adding the dangerous flower to the drink "with the intent to cause the victim harm," and knew it could result in death.

For all the latest news, politics, sports, and showbiz from the USA, go to

Jefferson City Police Department stated: "Authorities were notified by the victim that he believed a period of unexplained illnesses were in fact an intentional act of poisoning."

Teacher 'poisoned husband with deadly flower' for six weeks as he noticed signsJohn Christman, Executive Director of the school where Sceffer worked (ABC News)

The woman is currently being held at the Cole County jail without bond as police believe she may not appear in court.

Scheffer, who taught design and art at Calvary Lutheran High School in Jefferson City, is no longer listed on the school's website after her arrest. The school told ABC News that they've been informed by the cops about a "criminal matter pertaining to an employee" who is now on leave.

John Christman, the school's boss, said: "The alleged conduct was outside of the employee's association with the school and did not involve a student or any other school personnel."

He added: "As a Christian community, Calvary Lutheran High School believes in protecting the well-being of all individuals who are part of our programs and we seek to respond in a caring and sensitive manner to everyone in our school community."

* An AI tool was used to add an extra layer to the editing process for this story. You can report any errors to [email protected]

Connie Bowker

Teachers, Crime, Police, Murder

Read more similar news:

01.02.2023, 05:53 • Crime
Outrage as abandoned baby found in pram on beach, with mum off for a coffee
01.02.2023, 12:21 • Crime
Families told to stay inside church as armed cops chased dog that killed girl, 4
01.02.2023, 12:31 • Crime
Girl, 4, killed by dog in Milton Keynes attack to be mourned at community vigil
01.02.2023, 15:05 • Crime
Brit has fingertip bitten off by Russian woman in beach beanbag argument
01.02.2023, 17:14 • Crime
Man sues police when he loses his job after cops include him in fugitive list
02.02.2023, 02:39 • Crime
Double amputee's ex-wife insists he was 'no threat' as he was shot dead by cops
02.02.2023, 08:28 • Crime
Boy, 3, dies after being left in sweltering car in 34C heat 'throughout the day'
02.02.2023, 11:39 • Crime
Driver doing double the speed limit killed 2 boys as they played on their bikes
02.02.2023, 13:48 • Crime
Dances with Wolves star arrested on sex abuse claims 'armed cult against police'
02.02.2023, 20:20 • Crime
Unreleased Tyre Nichols footage set to show what cops said after fatal beating